Elon Musk Wins Appeal: $56B Tesla Pay Restored

Court Victory: Delaware Supreme Court Overturns Ruling and Restores Elon Musk’s $56 Billion Pay Deal

• The “Vindicated” CEO: Why the Supreme Court Called the Total Rescission “Inequitable”

• Nominal Damage: Why Musk Still Has to Pay $1 to the Shareholder Who Sued Him

• Wealth Explosion: How the 2018 Deal is Now Worth Roughly $139 Billion in 2025

• Texas vs. Delaware: How Tesla’s Relocation Changed the Legal Game for Future Lawsuits

• The $878 Billion Frontier: What the New 2025 Pay Plan Means for Tesla’s Trillion-Dollar Future

Also Read |Tamil Nadu Voter List Purge: 97 Lakh Names Deleted in SIR Phase 1

Elon Musk has officially “finished the fight” in Delaware. The thing is, after years of legal limbo, the Delaware Supreme Court has fully restored his 2018 Tesla pay package.⁴

Actually, the court’s 49-page ruling was a sharp reversal of Judge Kathaleen McCormick’s 2024 decision.⁵ Specifically, the justices argued that completely voiding the deal was an “inappropriate and inequitable” remedy.⁶ As a result, they noted that Musk had fully performed his end of the bargain, transforming Tesla into a global giant, and it would be wrong to leave him uncompensated for six years of work.⁷ Consequently, Musk took to X to declare himself “vindicated,” though the court did slap him with a symbolic $1 penalty for the “unfairness” of the original board process (those too).

Also Read |Tamil Nadu Voter List Purge: 97 Lakh Names Deleted in SIR Phase 1

And here’s the kicker. The $56 billion figure is now ancient history.

Basically, because Tesla’s stock has surged since 2018, those stock options are now estimated to be worth roughly $139 billion.⁹ Instead of a simple paycheck, this gives Musk the right to acquire about 304 million shares at a massive discount.¹⁰ In fact, combined with his other holdings, his net worth is now pushing toward the $680 billion mark. And then Y followed. Tesla’s board had warned that without this win, Musk might have shifted his focus entirely to SpaceX or xAI, but this ruling essentially anchors him to the EV maker for the foreseeable future (I checked this twice).

Also Read |Tamil Nadu Voter List Purge: 97 Lakh Names Deleted in SIR Phase 1

[Table: The Evolution of Elon Musk’s Tesla Pay Deals]

Moreover, the legal landscape for Tesla has fundamentally changed. Specifically, the company has moved its legal home from Delaware to Texas.¹¹

Actually, under Texas law, it’s much harder for small investors to sue over executive pay.¹² As a result, a new “3% rule” means a shareholder must own roughly $30 billion in stock before they can even file a similar lawsuit.¹³ Consequently, the new $878 billion package approved in November is much better protected from the kind of “activist judges” Musk previously railed against. And then Y followed. This new plan ties Musk to the company for another decade, with goals including a mind-bending $8.5 trillion market cap and the rollout of a million-strong robotaxi fleet (let’s be real, those are “Mars-level” targets).

Also Read |Tamil Nadu Voter List Purge: 97 Lakh Names Deleted in SIR Phase 1

The thing is, the Delaware “exit” might become a trend.

Basically, companies like Coinbase and Dropbox have already followed Tesla’s lead in moving to more founder-friendly states.

Instead of a tidy wrap-up, the legal world is watching to see if Delaware tries to soften its stance to stop the bleeding of corporate registrations.

And then Y followed. For now, Musk has his shares, Tesla has its CEO, and the focus shifts to whether “Optimus” robots can actually justify a trillion-dollar payday.

Also Read |Tamil Nadu Voter List Purge: 97 Lakh Names Deleted in SIR Phase 1

The post Elon Musk Wins Appeal: $56B Tesla Pay Restored first appeared on Business League.